In one word: Underwhelming
Third slice off the bucket list.
The pie shop has a good reputation and their posters are a bold claim - "Best in suburb". I was initially underwhelmed with their presentation in the cabinet, with a handful of small slices positioned together in paper cases ready for action surrounded by lots and lots of pies. The product itself was pleasant; creamy custard, flaky pastry and a thick dusting of icing sugar . I wasn't blown away with a vanilla flavour and craved more due to their slightly overpriced ($3.50), small size. Pies and a coffee also sampled and enjoyed. Best in area? Not sure until I try a few more in Richmond!